QUESTION: If I put a tank of water on the scales and it weighs 30 lbs. and I put a live 10 lb. fish in it. What will be the total weight of the tank and fish on the scale. How will buoyancy play in this, and what would happen if the fish died and sank to the bottom or floated to the top? ANSWER Bonnie P. Dalton on January 9, 1998: I believe while you are in an atmosphere with gravity, that is you are weighing the tank and fish here on earth, you will always have a total of 40 lbs whether the fish is in the tank or laying beside the tank while both are on the scale. Where the fish goes should be irrelevant while your weighing is being done under gravity conditions. ANSWER from Duncan Atchison on January 9, 1998: Total weight of the tank and fish would be 40 lbs, regardless of whether the fish remains alive or dies.